Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

At Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria, we keep things focused on making hot, satisfying pies with generous toppings and fresh ingredients every single day. Our counter is always stocked with plenty of options by the slice, whether you are stopping in for a quick lunch or bringing dinner home to the family. We love cooking up both classic comforts and bold creations, serving everything from golden cheese pies and warm garlic knots to our buffalo chicken and sweet Thai chili slices. That variety and welcoming counter service are at the heart of our kitchen. As Alex T. shared, our goal is to deliver what is "simple, fast, and done right... exactly what you hope for when you walk into a pizzeria." We take the time to talk through our daily specials, bake our crusts to a crisp golden brown, and make sure every bite hits the spot straight out of the oven. From hearty specialty pies to quick counter classics, we treat every order that comes across the counter with care. We are proud to keep our Farmingville neighborhood fed with great food and genuine, friendly service.